Butter and Crumb Pie Company

Sweet Pies

• Apple Crumb Pie

  Tart-sweet apples sprinkled with warm cinnamon spices and dark brown sugar baked in our handmade, signature all-butter pie crust and topped with sweet, buttery crumb topping. Served best warm with vanilla ice cream.

  $ 39.95

• Blueberry Crumb Pie

  A true classic. Luscious, juicy blueberries baked with fresh lemon and sugar in our handmade, signature all-butter pie crust and topped with sweet, buttery crumb topping. Served best warm with vanilla ice cream.

  $ 39.95

• Mixed Petite Crumb Pies

  Our 5-star petite crumb pies. A variety bundle which includes 2 Apple Crumb and 2 Blueberry Crumb petite pies. Each pie is baked in our signature all-butter pie crust and topped with sweet, buttery crumb topping. All are best served warm with vanilla ice cream.

  $ 39.95

• Chocolate Brownie Pie

  The ultimate brownie in a pie. Tastes just like your favorite dark chocolate chewy brownies baked in our handmade, signature all-butter pie crust. Served best with vanilla ice cream and chocolate sauce.

  $ 39.95

• Holiday Sampler

  Pick three of your favorite sweet pies and create the perfect dessert table that your guests will enjoy and remember for years to come. Choose from seasonal favorites like Apple or Blueberry Crumb and Pumpkin Praline, or select one of our other tasty pies including Chocolate Brownie, Chocolate Bourbon Pecan, or Key Lime!

  $ 113.95

Savory Pies

• Chicken Pot Pie

  Just like Grandma’s, but better. Tender white meat chicken, sautéed bacon, onions, and garlic, with carrots, mushrooms, and peas in a homemade creamy sherry roux baked together in our handmade, signature all-butter pie crust.

  $ 44.95

• Petite Chicken Pot Pies

  Petite chicken pot pies made from tender white meat chicken, sautéed bacon, onions, and garlic, with carrots, mushrooms, and peas in a homemade creamy sherry roux baked together in our handmade, signature all-butter pie crust.

  $ 44.95

• Meatloaf Mashed Potato Pie

  Comfort food, homemade. Juicy grass-fed beef sautéed with bacon, onions, and garlic layered on top of cheddar cheese, peas, and creamy mashed potatoes all baked in our handmade, signature all-butter pie crust.

  $ 44.95

• French Tomato Pie

  Our version of the classic French tomato tart. Juicy, vine-ripened tomatoes with spicy Dijon mustard, creamy Gruyere cheese, and Herbs de Provence baked in our handmade, signature all-butter pie crust. Serve with greens as a light meal or as a savory side dish.

  $ 44.95

• Supper Club Box

  Dinner made easy. Select your favorite 3 savory pies and get 3 dinners delivered to your door. From freezer to oven, pies store in the freezer for up to 6 months, and there is no thawing required to bake.

  $ 144.95

Cake & Cookies

• Carrot Cake

  Our secret recipe. A sweet and moist spice cake, full of cinnamon, carrots, and walnuts, covered in a deliciously sweet cream cheese frosting. Limited quantities are available.

  $ 44.95

• New York-style Crumb Cake

  This swoon-worthy treat brings us back to our childhood on the Jersey Shore with a moist and buttery cake topped with EXTRA cinnamon, brown sugar crumb topping, layered thick.

  $ 19.95

• Box of 6 Thick & Chunky Cookies

  Thick and chunky New York-style cookies. They are buttery with crispy edges, chewy centers, and come in a variety of flavors. A perfect gift to share or to keep for yourself. Each box contain 6 LARGE cookies weighing 6 oz. each (170g). Total box net weight is approximately 36 oz. (1021g).

  $ 29.95

Dinner & Dessert Box

• Dinner & Dessert Box

  Check dinner and dessert off your list. We’ll ship one savory pie and one sweet pie of your choice. To include a printed gift message, make sure to check the 'This is a gift' box. Gifts will include a pie server.

  $ 95.00

• 3 Months of Dinner & Dessert

  Check dinner and dessert off your list. Each month, we’ll ship one savory pie and one sweet pie of your choice. Pies will ship on the last Monday of each month and arrive within 2-3 business days.

  $ 340.00

Pie of the Month Club

• 3-Month Membership

  Each month, we’ll ship one pie from our selection of sweet varieties. When placing your order, select the month when you wish to begin the Pie of the Month Club membership. Pies will ship on the last Monday of every month and arrive within 2-3 business days.

  $ 170.00

• 6-Month Membership

  Each month, we’ll ship one pie from our selection of sweet varieties. When placing your order, select the month when you wish to begin the Pie of the Month Club membership. Pies will ship on the last Monday of every month and arrive within 2-3 business days.

  $ 364.00

• 12-Month Membership

  Each month, we’ll ship one pie from our selection of sweet varieties. When placing your order, select the month when you wish to begin the Pie of the Month Club membership. Pies will ship on the last Monday of every month and arrive within 2-3 business days.

  $ 754.00